Skip to Content

Lead Scoring

Understand how AI Prospecting scores leads for quality.

Scoring System

Each lead receives two scores:

  • Company Score (1-10) - How well the company fits your ICP
  • Contact Score (1-10) - How senior/relevant the contact is

Combined Score = Company + Contact (max 20)

Company Scoring (1-10)

The Evaluator scores companies based on four factors:

Value of Failure (35% weight)

How much revenue is lost per missed opportunity?

ScoreCriteria
9-10$10K+ lost per missed call
7-8$1K-$10K lost
4-6$100-$1K lost
1-3Minimal financial impact

Phone Dependency (30% weight)

Is phone the primary business channel?

ScoreCriteria
9-10Phone is critical (appointments, emergencies)
7-8Phone very important
4-6Phone used but not primary
1-3Mostly online business

Operational Complexity (20% weight)

Company structure and staffing.

ScoreCriteria
9-1010-50 employees, no dedicated receptionist
7-8Small team, stretched resources
4-6Has some front desk coverage
1-3Full reception team or too small

Decision Maker Access (15% weight)

How easy to reach decision makers?

ScoreCriteria
9-10Owner-operated, direct access
7-8Small leadership team
4-6Mid-size with some hierarchy
1-3Large corporate structure

Contact Scoring (1-10)

The Headhunter scores contacts by seniority:

TierScoreTitles
110Owner, Partner, Principal, Founder
29CEO, COO, CFO
38Office Manager, Practice Manager
47Director, VP, General Manager
56Manager, Supervisor

Rejected Contacts

These titles are excluded (score 0):

  • HR, Recruiting
  • IT, Engineering
  • Marketing, Sales
  • Administrative staff

Quality Tiers

Based on combined score:

TierScore RangeMeaning
Excellent18-20Top 10%, prioritize these
Good16-17Solid fits, follow up
Acceptable14-15Meet minimum threshold

Using Scores

Prioritize Outreach

Start with highest-scored leads. A 19/20 lead is much more likely to convert than a 14/20.

Filter in Leads Table

Sort by score to see best leads first.

Evaluate ICP Accuracy

If most leads score 14-15, your ICP might be too broad. Tighten criteria for better matches.

Score Display

In the leads table:

  • Company and contact scores shown separately
  • Combined score displayed
  • Color coding indicates tier